Ck3 too many duchies penalty. -- Original by Neutrino, aptly named "No Duchy Limit" Aug 4, 2019 · Kings and emperors with three or more duchies take an opinion penalty from all non-courtier vassals. Well, own without penalty. A standalone mod that removes the opinion penalties from holding too many duchies as a king or emperor. However, I wish we could hold 3 duchies as an emperor without a penalty. How does one get around this without giving vassals too much strength, or having them all fuming with resentment and factionalizing? You only get the “too many duchies” penalty if you are a king or an emperor. And you get "vassal desires duchy of X" opinion penalty, for every dejure count in duchy that is not in your capital. Jan 15, 2021 · I want to create a mod that increases the number of duchies a king and/or emperor could hold. Should be compatible with most mods. Well you can keep 2 duchies. I understand I need to grant some of my titles in order to get rid of this. It also increases discontent among factions, so when you freshly inherit, I'd recommend you to destroy the other duchies or else face rebelions and maybe create them later after short rule debuff has passed and factions were disbanded and all vassals like you. May 23, 2025 · Equally, this should never need updating, unless a duchy overhaul happens. Dukes can hold any number of duchies at no penalty. Like in your situation, let's say 7 of your titles fit into 2 duchies and the other two are in another duchy. Sep 25, 2022 · It seems odd that your vassals get pissed if you hold too many duchies, but not if you are an emperor holding 20 kingdoms. This can quickly add up into a large opinion debuff. You can own more but you get penalties to courtier opinions and tax income. So if you have too many duchies, you need to try to get the kingdom they're in and then give some duchies in the kingdom to vassals. Jan 20, 2015 · It's not that duchies are difficult to get rid of but the penalty has become unnecessary. com Nov 19, 2024 · The "too many duchies" penalty comes about when you hold more than two duchy titles as a king. Aug 2, 2022 · If we are talking about duchies in feudalism with built duchy buildings then keep them they are too valuable to not keep most of the time and holding several duchy capitals heavily outweighs the opinion penalty. duchy - The dejure counts get a -25 for "desiring duchy of ****" - You can have as many duchies as you'd like if you are Nov 12, 2024 · There isn't a duchy limit in the sense you are referring to. It makes no sense that a duke could hold as many duchies as he can have holdings (or vassals), but a king or emperor has a flat 2 duchy limit, with NO Too many duchies doesn't mean too many duchy lands held it means too many duchy titles held if you hold 3 or more it's too many with a 15 opinion penalty for each duchy too many give the titles away or destroy them personally I almost always tank the 15 opinion for 1 duchy too many because duchy buildings be crazy. Can I do anything against it? I could only think of not creating the duchy, but then I couldn‘t use the buildings… Dec 20, 2023 · It's been bothering me how you can't use more than 2 duchy buildings as most of them are really powerful, have any of you ever held more than 3 duchies and if so did you find it worth the opinion penalty? Therefore, one way to prevent this from being done by Kings and Emperors is to make it so you are limited by the number of duchies you can have (a soft limit), limiting how many counts you can have under you and also limits the number of duchy buildings you can have. The main issue is the negative opinion modifier which honestly isn't too bad if you realm is fairly small. Some realms can just ignore this, but at large Kingdom or Empire scale it's generally better to just limit to 2. What is stronger, a Duke with 5 buildings and 4 units of men at arms or an Emperor with 3 Too Many Duchies If you’re a King or Emperor, you can have too many duchy titles, and this will affect your vassals’ opinions. And not having duke vassals hurts your tech, and your levies. Apr 10, 2012 · I wonder if scrapping the too many held Duchies penalty and making held Duchies act as holdings for the purposes of Demesne limits would be better? Atm some areas with lots of small Duchies can be a huge pain, and in the latter the 2 'free' Duchy limit for Royals seems particularly arbitrary. I have fewer troops, am earning less, and when I grant duchy titles to get rid of the penalty, I'm told I'll lose land when the vassal dies. For another, you have two fewer stacks of men at arms relative to an Emperor. One of the objectively strongest ways of playing was always staying ducal level, having as many duchy titles as possible, and only holding the duchy capitals for each. Now my vassals are complaining that I hold too many duchies, what do I do? I don’t want to lose these direct holdings Mar 13, 2015 · Hello, I have seen many different answers to this question: - Your vassals get -10 for every third, fourth, fifth etc. Sep 14, 2020 · You have a limit to how many duchies you can personally own of 2. The purpose of the penalty is to discourage you from keeping your vassals at count level (by holding the duchies yourself), but now vassal limit does exactly that already. Please check your connection, disable any ad blockers, or try using a different browser. So I currently hold everything which is all of Ireland and a few other lands. It sounds like, when the Duke of Norfolk died and you inherited his land and title, you gave out the counties, but didn't give out the duchy title. There isn't an explicit penalty for holding many kingdoms (unlike, say, holding onto 3+ duchies); but if you have a large empire, you'll run into income and levy penalties from having too many direct vassals unless you start handing out kingdoms. Sep 17, 2020 · Too many dutchies aren't a big deal if you don't have many powerful vassals. May 19, 2024 · Having vassals more directly owning the land also means more tax (levies too, but well, we don't really care that much about levies, do we?) in CK3 (as every person between you and the holding passes a fraction of the tax forward), so having dukes as direct vassals and counts under them limits your income somewhat. If you need to hold more titles that you can fit into duchies, and don't want vassals to hate you, just make sure the duchies aren't made. You can stay as a Duke and hoard those duchy buildings, yes, but you are limited in other ways as a Duke. How many duchies is too many duchies? You guys must know how much of a bitch the opinion penalty for having too many duchies can be. Holding more than two duchy titles will reduce vassal opinion by -15 for each extra title. The problem is doing this makes my realm worse. See full list on ck3. For one, you have the vassal limit of 20. However, kings and emperors are restricted to holding a maximum of 2 duchy titles before penalties kick in. Oct 20, 2020 · As the title suggest I have the negative "too many duchies" opinion coming from many Vassels yet my domain is 1/5how is this possible? Feudal elective rulers receive penalty if holding too many elector titles, so one could increase that penalty to offset getting rid of multiple duchies penaliztion. If you are not worried about vassal unhappiness, fine, but each duchy is a -15 penalty to their opinion. It's always good to hold 2 duchies when you are a kingdom or emperor. Jan 31, 2023 · Have you been met with the warning message "too many held Duchies" in Crusader Kings 3? Here is how to fix it. Without penalty. . That opinion penalty is -10 for each duchy above two (generally, you'll want to keep the de jure duchy of your capital). If you hold 3 duchies your vassals will dislike you with minus 15. Kings and Emperors have a soft-cap of holding duchies themselves, as every duchy after the second (#s 3+) gives a 'Too Many Duchies' opinion penalty with other vassals. So I like to have as many holdings as possible as they give way more gold. --- A standalone mod that removes the opinion penalties from holding too many duchies as a king or emperor. Giving your heir duchies without counties/baronies to give him power doesn't help him much. You can only hold a total of 2 duchies without a penalty. I created the Kingdom of Ireland and got the penalty "Too Many Held Duchies". Oct 2, 2023 · In CK3, counts can hold as many duchies as they want with no issues. If its still tribal then it really doesn't matter too much. Whe pros were mentioned, the cons are quite significat too though, you get opinion debuff for each duchy above limit. paradoxwikis. How do you deal with the duchy limit? If I want to hold 4 duchy capitals and also use their special duchy buildings as a king or emperor, I have a huge penalty. szze yxwucyq udojx garevv lqk 9nk2h nnke gd utbh pw9